Skip to main content

Posts

Your brand crosses borders — is your trademark protected?

  Indian trademark law · Well-known marks · Foreign brand protection A foreign brand can walk into a courtroom in India — even without a single sale or a trademark registration here — and still win. That is the promise of the doctrine of transborder reputation. But 2025–26 judgments remind us it is a conditional promise, and conditions matter. What is transborder reputation? In a world of Instagram, international travel, and Amazon storefronts, a brand's reputation does not stop at a customs gate. The principle of transborder reputation acknowledges that goodwill can "spill over" into markets where a business has no physical footprint — through media, the internet, tourist exposure, and cross-border advertising. Indian courts have long recognised this reality. The landmark was N.R. Dongre v. Whirlpool Corporation (1996) , where the Supreme Court upheld a passing-off action by a foreign brand against a registered Indian mark, holding that international magazine advertisem...

IPAB has allowed an appeal and granted patent to Pfizer for Tofacitinib and its salts

                                                    In a decision dated 21st August 2020 IPAB vide its  Order  has allowed an appeal and granted Patent  to Appellant M/s. PFIZER PRODUCTS INC., USA  for Tofacitinib and its salts. The appeal is against the   order dated 3 rd  September 2015 passed by the Controller of Patents under Section 15 of the Indian Patents Act, whereby the Appellant’s Indian patent application no. 00991/MUMNP/2003 was rejected on the ground that it is hit by section 13(1)(b) and being non-patentable under section 3(d). The Appellant requested for an urgent hearing of the matter and IPAB considered the request for urgent hearing and passed the present order.  This Patent application claimed the compound 3-{(3R,4R)-4-Methyl-3-[methyl-(7H-pyrrolo[2,3-d]pyrimidin-4-yl)-amino]-piper...

Honourable Justice Manmohan Singh Tenure as Chairman of IPAB (Intellectual Property Appellate Board) extended for Another three months

  The Supreme Court on September 16, 2020 has extended the tenure of Honourable Justice Manmohan Singh as Chairman of IPAB (Intellectual Property Appellate Board)  for another three months.  Justice Manmohan Singh was appointed on July 2017 for a term of three years.  However as per the rules governing the appointment his term would come to an end on attaining retirement age of 65 years on 22nd September 2019. Since Government has not appointed any Chairman thereafter, on a Petition by International Association for Protection of Intellectual Property (AIPPI) the Supreme Court has extended his term for another year i.e, till 21st September 2020 as the Petitioner claimed that IPAB will be Defunct with his retirement thereby causing hardship several litigants. The Central Government has notified in March 2020 that Justice Singh will continue as the chairman of IPAB up to September 21, 2020, or until further orders, whichever is earlier.  Now with this extension, Ho...

Mark used for different class of goods/services would not be detrimental to the purported distinctive character or repute

SUPREME COURT in it's Order dated  26 July, 2018 held that use of the mark "NANDHINI" for Restaurant Services and running Hotels is not detrimental to the repute and usage of the mark "NANDHINI" for Milk and Milk Products. VS. In  M/S. Nandhini Deluxe vs M/S. Karnataka Cooperative Milk., l ong legal battle for Trademark Registration of Nandhini Trademark for Restaurant and Hotel business has been successful for M/s. Nandhini Deluxe. The Supreme Court observed that  all the ingredients laid down in  Section 11(2)  of the Act, as explained by the Delhi High Court in Nestle India Ltd., have not been satisfied. We are not persuaded to hold, on the facts of this case, that the appellant has adopted the trade mark to take unfair advantage of the trade mark of the respondent. We also hold that use of ‘NANDHINI’ by appellant in respect of its different goods would not be detrimental to the purported distinctive character or repute of the trade ...

Punitive Damages for Infringement of Trade Dress by Delhi High Court in an Interim Application

Delhi High Court vide its Judgement dated 31st July 2018 in  Louboutin-3 case has granted permanent injunction and punitive damages against a Delhi based retailer for infringing the famed ‘Red Sole’ trademark of Christian Loubutin.  The Plaintiff‟s "RED SOLE" trademark, i.e. , wherein a specific tone of colour red (Pantone no. 18.1663TP) is applied to the outsole of a shoe, is unique in its own accord and became known in the world of fashion only after being introduced by the Plaintiff herein as their Trade Dress. The consumers in India identify the Plaintiff as the sole proprietor of the Christian Louboutin trademarks including the "RED SOLE" trademark and any use of the said trademarks by an unrelated entity will entail taking undue advantage of the reputation and goodwill of the Plaintiff, which has been built painstakingly over the several decades; The Defendants are located in Kamla Nagar Market, New Delhi, who were found to be dealing in infringing...

Hasbro, Inc. (RHODE ISLAND CORPORATION) granted Scent Trademark

I was always amused by the smell/scent of Hasbro Play-Doh while my kids playing with them. On 15th May 2018,  Hasbro gets U.S. trade mark Reg. No. 5,467,089 for the particular smell of Play-doh brand modeling compound for " a scent of a sweet, slightly musky, vanilla fragrance, with slight overtones of cherry, combined with the smell of a salted, wheat-based dough". The Trademark Registration has gained significance since it is one of the non-conventional trademark being scent that is granted in recent years by United States Patent and Trademark office (USPTO). Other important aspect of the Trademark Registered in  International Class 28 for "Toy Modeling Compounds".  Hasbro also claimed that it is in the market since 12th September 1955 and recorded the same as first usage of the scent in the market. Our sources reveal that the present Registration of Scent Mark is one of 13 Active Registrations for Scent marks from USPTO. The rece...

Tata's Herbal Tea fails to get patent protection

The patent office has refused to grant a patent to Tata Global Beverages (formerly known as Tata Tea) for its 'invention' regarding a process for preparation of flavoured herbal tea. Based on the opposition filed by Hindustan Unilever Limited (HUL) and TATA Tea failed to provide sufficiency of disclosure of the invention the Controller of Patents refused to grant patent.   Tata Global  Beverages, the patent application has claimed a new flavoured herbal tea composition comprising 1% to 8% of Darjeeling Broken, 10% to 50% of flavour concentrate and the rest being tea particles. Tata Global Beverages had submitted the patent filing without appropriate clarification for the unique taste for the tea composition. It was unable to find out the technical advancement of the application as compared to the existing knowledge. Thus controller had to refuse the grant of patent. Source:  http://www.financialexpress.com/article/markets/commodities/tata-global-bev...

Indian IP Law is Under Judicial Scanner

Indian IP Law is Under Judicial Scanner Key provisions of IPAB (Intellectual Property Appellate Board) are struck down as unconstitutional in a writ petition by Madras High Court. As the awareness is being spread among IPR laws in India, the legislation on IPR and its impact on the common citizen is under Judicial scanner and we are expecting more such writ petitions being queued up in near future. It is for the first time Indian Intellectual Property rights Legislation are subject to the Judicial review and we can expect more such occasions in near future. Let us all hope for the better, unbiased and more citizen friendly IPR legislation in India.

Common or General name descriptive terms of the products are not eligible for grant of injunctions - Micronix India vs Mr. J.R. Kapoor 2003 (26) PTC 593 Del

Common or General name descriptive terms of the products are not eligible for grant of injunctions - The Supreme Court observed that micro-chip technology being the basis of many of the electronic products, the word "micro" has much relevance in describing the products and therefore no one can claim monopoly over the use of the said word. Anyone producing any product with the use of micro-chip technology would be justified in using the said word as a prefix to his trade name and thus who are familiar with the use of electronic goods know fully well and are not likely to be misguided or confused merely by the prefix `micro' in the trade name. Thus, in the nutshell, the Supreme Court has held that once it is found that the word `micro' is a common or general name descriptive of the products which are sold or of the technology by which the products are manufactured, the users of such products are not likely to be misguided or confused by the said word.

Adopting a Mark which is general to Trade i.e., several traders using the same would not entitle injunctions in the Court -Skyline Education Institute ... vs S.L.Vaswani & Anr (AIR 2010 SC 3221)

Adopting a Mark which is general to Trade i.e., several traders using the same would not entitle injunctions in the Court The Apex Court in the case of Skyline Education Institute ... vs S.L.Vaswani & Anr  (AIR 2010 SC 3221) held that if a particular word is common to the trade in that if it is widely used by several traders and thereby it becomes generic such marks would not entitle injunctions if copied by other traders. Para 17- In the light of the above, we shall now consider whether the impugned order is vitiated by an error of law apparent on the face of the record or refusal of the High Court to grant injunction in terms of the prayer made by the appellant has resulted in manifest injustice. A little journey in the backdrop of the case shows that the only ground on which the appellant sought temporary injunction against the respondents was that the word `Skyline' is a specific/distinct word and being a prior user, it was entitled to seek a restraint against ...

Interim Relief - Temporary Injunctions- should not be based on Affidavits alone- Mujeeb Modern Rice Mills v. P. Doraisamy Gounder, (2010) 15 SCC 459

Interim Relief - Temporary Injunctions- should not be based on Affidavits alone -  (2010) 15 SCC 459 The Apex Court held that temporary injunctions or any interim relief cannot be granted merely by filing affidavits without any documentary evidence. For granting Interim Relief the court should consider the prima facie case established on the bases of the documentary evidence. Mere filing of affidavit would not entitle parties Interim Relief. S. 106 - Interim relief - Grant of - Determination of prior use - In absence of any evidence and only on affidavits -Impermissibility - Counter-suits for restraining use of Maharaja brand unregistered trademark by appellant and respondent against each other, both selling packaged rice - Division Bench of High Court granting interim relief to respondent in absence of documentary evidence and based solely on affidavits, concluding respondent was using trade mark prior in point of time to appellant - Impermissibility of - Held, it is in...

K. Narayanan And Anr vs S. Murali on 5 August, 2008 - (2008) 10 SCC 479

CAN MERELY FILING A TRADEMARK APPLICATION FOR A MARK CONSTITUTES PASSING OFF? The court in the case of K.Narayana and Another Vs. S.Murali held that merely filing a Trademark does not constitute passing off. For Passing Off need to be established, there should be  misrepresentation in the course of trade which is very essential  ingredient for establishment of the passing off case. The relevant paragraphs from the judgement are provided below:- Para 23- It was finally argued by the learned counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent before us, that, by merely filing a trade mark application, the respondent did not misrepresent in the course of trade that his goods were the goods of the appellants and therefore there was no cause of action for filing a suit for passing off, which necessarily required sale of one's goods deceptively as though it were the goods of another. Para 24- Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and after carefully examining ...

Corporate privacy: Cracking down on intellectual property rights violators

Microsoft's is turning up the heat on Intellectual property rights' violators. About a week ago, they took a local company to court, which was allegedly using the software gaint's Intellectual property, without a license to do so. Microsoft's immediate focus is corporate piracy in pakistan , including medium and small oranizations- where organisations have the ability to pay.

South Indian Movie producer uses technological measure to identify copyright infringement

Leading south Indian Tollywood production house Geetha Arts has sent a legal notice to PVR Cinemas, demanding Rs. 5 crores compensation for allegedly contributing to the piracy and infringement of their copyright in its recently release movie "100% Love". The anti-piracy teams of Geetha Arts recently seized some pirated DVDs of the film from various places in the state and on verification of the forensic watermarks on the pirated copies of "100% Love" reportedly established that the pirated copies were made from a master copy recorded at Screen 6, PVR Ambience Mall, Gurgaon, Haryana. Based on this evidence, Geetha Arts owner Allu Aravind has claimed damages from PVR Cinemas for failing to protect their intellectual property, abetting piracy by allowing a master copy to be recorded at their facility. Movie Industry is carefully watching this development for enforcement of copyrights in future.

Suven life Sciences Shares up

The Hyderabad-based pharmaceuticals company Suven Life Sciences acquired one patent each from Europe, New Zealand, Australia and Korea for the treatment of disorders associated with neurodegenerative diseases. The news helped Suven Life Sciences shares gaining around 5% after the company acquired the patents.

India likely to join Madrid System

With the pace Trademark Registry working in INDIA and the pending Draft Trademark Amendment Bill 2009 it is more likely that India will sign Madrid Agreement within this year. Indian companies and individuals should save themselves from foreign applications and Registration. It is advisable to file and protect the trademark applications by Indian before India sign Madrid Agreement.

CIPLA seeks for Compulsory License

Recently CIPLA filed an application before Indian Patent Office seeking for the grant of Compulsory License against Merck’s Anti- HIV Drug, Isentress. CIPLA filed this application of Compulsory License on the ground that “Isentress is not available in the market at reasonable and affordable price”. It is known that the Act under Sec 84 provided certain grounds for granting Compulsory License, which principally includes the ground “Not available to public at Reasonable Price”. The term “Reasonably affordable price” must be construed according to the present circumstances prevailing in India”. The price fixed by the Merck & Co. is $7 (USD), which is not “reasonable” to the public in India. Hence the term “Reasonably affordable price” must be given utmost importance while disposing this application. Till now the patent offices in India have never laid down any boundaries to the pricing of drugs, hope they will at least do it now.